The harmful and potentially deadly impacts of increasing global temperatures on human health are already being felt in parts of the world.

At a large industrial sugarcane mill in Nicaragua, the Adelante Initiative is investigating how access to water and rest in shade together with better equipment, might improve work conditions and prevent chronic kidney disease of non-traditional origin (CKDnt) among workers while preserving their productivity.

This type of research furthers the overall understanding of who is impacted by climate change as well as how can the income and health of those working in a warmer world can be protected.

A worker in Nicaragua toils without adequate PPE or other mitigations against heat strain. Photo credit: Ed Kashi/VII

“For the communities at the heart of this epidemic, the Adelante initiative has had a very positive impact, generating a change in the life perspective of people affected by CKDnt. Personally, I have lost several family members including grandparents, uncles, cousins, and even my dad who passed away at the age of 43. CKDnt ended the dreams of entire families.

Nowadays, thanks to the improvement of the working conditions of the Adelante initiative and the understanding of the causes of CKDnt, workers encourage their children to go to school instead of replacing them in the field because there is hope that parents will continue working with less fear of acquiring the disease, and the children can study. The impression is the interventions of the Adelante program have decreased the mortality rate in the communities and the community economies are changing positively.

It is important to note that the psychological damage that someone in the family is condemned to get sick at work is decreasing and that is something very important, thanks to the interventions of the Adelante program.”

– William Martinez, Former child sugarcane laborer, current Adelante Initiative researcher and community leader

“Para las comunidades en el corazón de esta epidemia, la iniciativa Adelante ha impactado de manera muy positiva, generando un cambio en la perspectiva de vida de las personas afectadas por ERCD. Personalmente, he perdido varios familiares incluyendo abuelos, tíos, primos e incluso mi papá quien falleció a la edad de 43 años. ERCD terminó con los sueños de familias enteras.

Actualmente gracias a la mejora de las condiciones laborales de la iniciativa Adelante y la comprensión de las causas de la ERCD, los trabajadores animan a sus hijos a ir a la escuela en lugar de reemplazarlos en el campo porque hay esperanza de que los padres continúen trabajando con menos temor de adquirir la enfermedad, y los hijos pueden estudiar. La impresión es las intervenciones del programa Adelante se ha disminuido la tasa de mortalidad en las comunidades y las economías comunitarias están cambiando positivamente.

Es importante destacar que el daño psicológico de que alguien de la familia está condenado a enfermarse en el trabajo está disminuyendo y es algo muy importante, gracias a las intervenciones del programa Adelante.”

– William Martinez, ex niño trabajador de la caña de azúcar, actual investigador de la Iniciativa Adelante y líder comunitario

Background

One of the pressing challenges facing the world is the impact of increasing global temperatures and water shortage (driven by both climate change and population expansion) on human health and productivity. Heat stress is a physical hazard that negatively affects productivity while also increasing accident rates and the risk of heat illness or injury in workers. Importantly, dehydration, which can occur quickly when undertaking physical work in hot environments, conflates the effects and risks of heat stress. Common incentives such as piecework exacerbate these risks. Thus, excessive heat exposure is a serious occupational health problem that will rapidly escalate as global temperatures and water shortages increase.

In some parts of the world, excessive heat exposure already presents a serious threat. An example of this is the epidemic of chronic kidney disease of non-traditional origin (CKDnt) that is highly prevalent in sugarcane workers in Central America and has resulted in tens of thousands of early deaths in this region over the last 30 years.

Currently, treatment scenarios are suboptimal. Infection due to poor living conditions and other factors make home peritoneal dialysis a complicated proposition for addressing the needs of those already ill. Photo credit: Ed Kashi/VII

The risk factors for CKDnt are probably multiple, but there is a growing body of evidence that labour practices, specifically strenuous work in heat without sufficient rest or hydration, is an important driver of the disease. Thus, this disease has a direct link to climate change, with prevalence likely to increase in the near future unless workplace heat stress is mitigated.

As a response to this heat stress related disease, the Adelante Initiative has been implemented at a large sugarcane mill in Nicaragua. Adelante is a scientific evaluation of workplace interventions that focus on adequate water and rest in shade together with improved ergonomics, designed to prevent CKDnt among workers while preserving productivity. Due to the high prevalence of CKDnt among sugarcane workers, this initiative is primarily focused on this sector; from there it will be adapted to other geographies and industries.

The Challenge

A major challenge is getting key stakeholders and industry regulators to recognise the serious and far-ranging impacts of excessive heat exposure on human health and productivity.

A further challenge is the widespread use of piece rate work in developing economies. Piece rate work determines that workers are paid according to the number of units produced as oppose to the time spent on the job and can strongly influence workers to ignore or temper necessary worker protections.

Engaging key stakeholders in all parts of the global commodity chain (e.g., from local industry to the global consumer) in the promotion and practice of meaningful worker protections and sustainable production/consumption is a complicated process in itself.

Former sugarcane worker Ramon Uriel Munguia, pictured at 27, now deceased from CKDnt, lost his father to the same disease. Photo credit: Ed Kashi/VII Photo credit: Ed Kashi/VII

Climate and health solutions

As part of the Adelante Initiative, a set of evidence-based recommendations (such as on installing shade tents and water containers), actionable toolkits and educational materials has been created and distributed among those affected and those wishing to improve protections for workers in industrial agricultural work, and other manual outdoor work.

The experience and knowledge gained from the Adelante Initiative is also being used to inform work with other industries with workers at-risk of excessive heat exposure.

An overhead diagram of the basic material required for shade tents used in the Adelante Initiative

Progress achieved

Following the implementation of a workplace intervention that improved access to water and rest in shade together with improved ergonomics, there was a reduction in the number of heat stress events and heat-related hospitalization in the cohort. Furthermore, the proportion of workers with kidney injury decreased following an enhanced rest schedule and improved intervention implementation.

The evidence gain from the Adelante Initiative was used to advocate and insert improved worker protections in the certification standards of Bonsucro and Fair Trade USA – both leaders in certification of sustainably produced sugarcane and other key food commodities.

Other Sugar mills have begun to address excessive heat exposure for their workers by implementing programs informed by Adelante’s intervention.

The benefit to industry is clear on an ethical plane, but this study has also demonstrated a positive return on investment for those undertaking such worker protection measures.

Workers rest under a shade tent with access to potable water and electrolyte solution at the Ingenio San Antonio in Nicaragua. Photo credit: Ed Kashi/VII

Lessons learned

  • When aiming to improve worker protection and work conditions, productivity and potential changes to productivity must be considered and measured, as productivity reductions (perceived or real) will undermine the successful implementation of a workplace intervention.
  • Safer work practices can improve productivity and return on investment. It is critical to demonstrate this where possible to support the promotion and implementation of worker protection policies.
  • Successful workplace intervention implementation depends on understanding the objectives at all management and worker levels. To be successful, worker protections and workplace interventions must align with these objectives otherwise “doing things as we always have” will win out.
  • Successful and effective workplace intervention must be culturally appropriate.
  • It is critical to engage early and regularly with all key stakeholders so that stakeholders are involved in the design, adoption, adaption (if necessary) and implementation. Identifying stakeholders’ key objectives (e.g., economic, health, social) is important to successfully implementing effective and enduring interventions.
  • The positive impacts of successful worker protections and workplace interventions can be far ranging. Where possible, it is important to disseminate outputs to worker communities, industry policy makers and regulators (e.g., management, certifying institutions, governing bodies) and funders (e.g., development banks, consumer associations) and health systems.

Next steps

As the fundamentals of intervention implementation and work to improve systems management is being refined, the organisers of the Adelante initiative are collaborating with leaders in technology to allow employers, and workers affordable ways to monitor their health and provide improved protection at work. They are working towards implementing workplace interventions that reduce occupational heat exposure in other at-risk occupations (e.g., construction) and populations (e.g., migrant workers), and also on improving law and certification standards at local and international levels while advising development institutions and programs. Finally, this initiative is aiming to examine the effects of early-life exposure due to child labour and provide adequate protections on lower resource farms and worksites.

The text of this case study is based on the submission from the case study lead organization received through the 2021 WHO call for case studies on health and climate change, and does not endorse or reflect the views of the World Health Organization or any of its activities.